Selden and Centereach Auto Repair

Great staff and very helpful

TLDR: I will not be returning because I (a young person) was nearly scammed and taken advantage of for a $400+ job. I had been going to this place for years. As a 21 year old new to cars it would be easy to be taken advantage of but Keith (the manager) always made me feel safe about my car and I always felt like I was being given a fair shake and never being taken advantage of. Until my last oil change, when Keith wasn’t there and a young kid performed my oil change. He comes out to tell me I need new front brakes on the car (a $400+ job). He tells me they’re less than 25% and that I need to have them replaced soon rotors too. I knew this to be a scam since I had only just gotten new brakes in January. So I take it to another mechanic and sure enough, I don’t need brakes. I will not be coming back here as I no longer trust them. I cannot recommend.

friendly services

Always great service. Highly recommend.

Fast, Efficient and Professional service!

Incredibly fast service, a decent price, they have an online tracker where you can decline or approve any services they recommend, and they staff was very kind

Great people , always accommodating And get the job done.

Always efficient, polite and thorough.

The staff at Middle Country Auto are top notch. They diagnose any issue that I bring to their attention and keep me advised of any issues that may arise. They are extremely efficient, professional and caring. The pricing is fair and I would recommend Middle Country Auto to anyone needing repairs or maintenance.

So after Mother Nature helped to destroy my engine with her flood waters the staff at MCA II once again saved my 2015 Avalon Hybrid with their expertise. They met with the insurance assessor, who said that Jeremy was very professional and thorough in his cost estimate, ordered a new engine in a timely fashion, and installed it quick as lightning! The car is running GREAT and I am very happy with the repair. Thank you once again keeping my vehicle on the road!!!